HELP!

Oh, Lordy. I need help. Bad.
Is anyone out there as terrible at decision-making as I am???
The left one is “trendier” and has a bigger face (and it’s pink!), but the right one is classic, and I wouldn’t be tired of it ten years from now. Also, my wrist is pretty small, which complicates things.
Which one should I get?? Help a girl out.
Love, Cait

Leave a Comment

49 Comments

  1. I love the Gramercy Grand! It's not too pinky, and I personally love bigger watches!

    4.9.12Reply
  2. Hi Caitlin!
    I'm new to the blogging world – I don't blog, but I do have a long list of blogs I love to read now and then. I stumbled across your blog and I love reading your posts. It's now on my must-read list! With the watches, even though I like them both, I would personally go for the "Gramercy Crystal". Hope I have helped a bit!
    Emily

    4.9.12Reply
  3. Left, definitely! I wouldnt say it was trendy, just classic and fun!

    4.9.12Reply
  4. Anonymous

    I'm really indecisive too, so I understand how you feel! I too have really small wrists, so unless you really like large watch faces, I'd go for the Gramercy Crystal. Even though the pink is cute, I think the size of the crystal one is better. Plus it's really pretty too!
    Good luck with your decision, and remember, you'll end up loving either one of them, so don't worry!
    Have a great day!

    4.9.12Reply
  5. Both watches are great, but I personally prefer the Gramercy Grand over the Gramercy Crystal! I don't think it's "trendy" at all and the pink is a nice touch =) I also like how the Grand lets you know what day it is – that's always a plus!

    SHF
    thechroniclesofs.blogspot.com

    4.9.12Reply
  6. Right one, it's more timeless!

    4.9.12Reply
  7. I love the pink one, but I'd probably go with the more classic watch, just because it won't ever be out of style.

    4.9.12Reply
  8. 100% Gramercy Crystal – It will totally match with everything and you won't have to worry about your stack fitting in with the pink in the other one! Good luck making a decision πŸ™‚

    4.9.12Reply
  9. That's a tough choice, but I would have to go with the gramercy grand bc I love the touch of pink! So glad to find your blog!

    4.9.12Reply
  10. Unless you have a lot of disposable income, I am going to say classic. Also, I like the way the classic crystal one looks on your wrist. Hope you had a good Easter.

    4.10.12Reply
  11. Okay, I LOVE the left. I don't think it is too trendy at all. I know it is large, but I don't think it overwhelms your wrist at all.

    4.10.12Reply
  12. I'd go for the right! Just a little more timeless and flattering.

    4.10.12Reply
  13. I like the crystal on the right – it will never go out of style!

    4.10.12Reply
  14. LOVE the left! I don't think it is too big on your wrist!

    4.10.12Reply
  15. Gramercy crystal! While I'd like to think you'd never get sick of pink, the classic is timeless. It looks much better on your wrist size-wise too. Get it!!

    4.10.12Reply
  16. I vote #2 as a fellow tiny wristed girl

    4.10.12Reply
  17. Such a tough decision–I love them both! Plus all of the comments seem to be split right down the middle haha. My first instinct was that I liked gramercy grand, but the more I looked at them I decided I liked crystal better! I like the size of it on your wrist, plus I like the fact that there's no color in it. Either choice will be great though!

    4.10.12Reply
  18. I like the gramercy crystal!! They're both gorgeous though!

    4.10.12Reply
  19. LOVE the pink one, but the other one looks best on your wrist!
    πŸ™‚
    xx

    4.10.12Reply
  20. i like the grand! nothin wrong with a pop of pink πŸ™‚

    4.10.12Reply
  21. Gramercy crystal, always need a little sparkle

    4.10.12Reply
  22. I love them both but I would go for the one on the right because it's more classic. Good Luck!!

    4.10.12Reply
  23. I like the classic (Grand). I love pink, but like you said, ten years from now you might not love it as much.

    4.10.12Reply
  24. They're both pretty fabulous, but I'd probably go with the classic one. You'll wear it forever!

    4.10.12Reply
  25. I am super indecisive, it's bad. I love both of these so either one will be a great choice. I personally would probably end up with the more classic looking one just so I could wear it for years.

    4.10.12Reply
  26. I love the gramercy crystal!! But really both are super cute!

    4.10.12Reply
  27. I don't think you can go wrong with either, but I love the gramercy grand!

    4.10.12Reply
  28. tough choice!!!! id go with the one on the right…

    4.10.12Reply
  29. I am awful at making decisions. I would probably go with the one on the right since it is classical and the one on the left is trendy. Can't wait to see which you pick. xo

    4.10.12Reply
  30. Initially I loved the pink one beat but after seeing it on your wrist … Definitely the classic one!!!

    4.10.12Reply
  31. I am always being told I need to be better at making decisions, so I feel your pain! My vote is for the right one, gramercy crystal!

    4.10.12Reply
  32. I'd go with the smaller face, but they're both fabulous!
    Thanks for stopping by Fashion Truffles today. I'm now following πŸ™‚
    fashiontruffles.blogspot.com

    4.10.12Reply
  33. I vote for the one on the right… when in doubt, always go with the classic!

    4.11.12Reply
  34. i'd go for the crystal one, it's so much more classic and you'll wear it for such a long time, while the one with pink will maybe get boring faster & not stay trendy forever πŸ™‚

    4.11.12Reply
  35. I like the face of the solid gold one a little more, it's kind of capiz shell looking πŸ™‚

    4.11.12Reply
  36. I love the one on the left!!!! I love the subtle pink look!!! And i live the bigger faced ones!!! Hope this helps!

    4.11.12Reply
  37. I would get the regular crystal one!

    4.11.12Reply
  38. Crystal gets my vote!

    4.11.12Reply
  39. Ahh! Love them both! I say go for the pink! It's has a little something extra!

    xx
    Giovanna
    http://www.oliveandanarrow.com
    ShabbyApple Gift Card Giveaway!

    4.11.12Reply
  40. Definitely the classic one. So pretty!

    4.11.12Reply
  41. The classic!

    4.11.12Reply
  42. I vote for the grand! Love the pop of pink!

    4.12.12Reply
  43. definitely the one on the right… it's so pretty.

    4.12.12Reply
  44. To precious. Your blog is so lovely! I am giving away $50 to ASOS and I would love for you to stop by an enter!
    xoxo
    Morgan
    http://thesocialboutique.blogspot.com/2012/04/50-to-asos-giveaway.html

    4.12.12Reply
  45. the one on the left! i love the little pop of pink!!!!

    bijou-minou.blogspot.com

    4.13.12Reply
  46. I say crystal all the way…it's more elegant and classy!

    4.13.12Reply
  47. I like the touch of hot pink!

    4.16.12Reply
  48. I personally would go with the smaller watch-I think it's a bit more timeless and I have small wrists too so I understand where you are coming from!

    4.17.12Reply
  49. Anonymous

    I am currenly trying to make this exact same decision now except with both watches in silver as I already have a gold watch in a different style. I also have very small wrists and I'm awful at decision making! Which did you end up choosing??

    10.10.12Reply